Name: Creamy Homemade Potato Salad Perfect for Summer BBQs
Prep time: 20 min
Cook time: 10 min
Total time: 50 min
Ingredients: 3 pounds Russet Potatoes (Peeled and cubed); 1 tablespoon Kosher Salt (For boiling); 1/2 cup Distilled White Vinegar (Substitute with apple cider vinegar if desired); 1 cup Mayonnaise (Adjust for richness); 1 cup Celery (Chopped); 1/3 cup Dill Pickle Relish (Or finely diced dill pickles); 1/2 cup Red Onions (Diced); 1/4 cup Minced Parsley; 1 tablespoon Yellow Mustard (Dijon mustard can be used); 1 teaspoon Black Pepper; 1 teaspoon Onion Powder; 4 large Hard Boiled Eggs (Finely diced)

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

As I stood under the sun on a perfect summer afternoon, the aroma of grilled burgers wafted through the air, transporting me back to joyful family picnics. That’s when I realized it was time to whip up my Classic American Potato Salad with Creamy Dressing. A timeless essential for any BBQ, this potato salad strikes the ideal balance between creamy and tangy, making it a surefire crowd-pleaser. With just a handful of ingredients and real mix-and-match potential, you can create a dish that’s not only comforting but also versatile enough to shine on its own or alongside grilled delights. And the best part? It’s make-ahead friendly, meaning you can spend more time enjoying the day and less time in the kitchen. So, are you ready to dive into this potato paradise and discover how easily you can personalize it for your next gathering?

Why is potato salad a must-have?

Crowd-pleaser: This classic dish is guaranteed to delight your guests at any summer BBQ or family picnic.

Creamy Delight: With a perfect blend of mayo and tangy vinegar, every bite is a taste sensation.

Customizable: Feel free to add your own twist—try a Hawaiian-inspired version with pineapple or crispy bacon!

Make-ahead friendly: Prep this potato salad in advance so you can focus on grilling and socializing.

Easy to Make: Just a few simple ingredients and steps ensure success without the stress.

Once you’ve mastered this recipe, you’ll want to experiment with other side dishes like Peach Salad Summer or Corn Salad Savory to keep the flavor train rolling!

Potato Salad Ingredients

• Here’s everything you need to create your creamy potato salad.

For the Salad

Russet Potatoes – The best choice for a fluffy texture; always peel and cut them into ¾-inch cubes for even cooking.
Kosher Salt – Essential for boiling; it enhances the flavor of the potatoes as they cook.
Distilled White Vinegar – Adds a tangy kick; marinate the potatoes in vinegar for deeper flavor (substitute with apple cider vinegar if desired).
Mayonnaise – The creamy star of the show; adjust the amount based on your personal preference for richness.
Celery – A crunchy addition that adds freshness; use yellow or green celery based on availability.
Dill Pickle Relish – Offers sweetness and acidity; feel free to swap it for finely diced dill pickles for a bolder taste.
Red Onions – Imparts a sharp flavor; substitute with green onions if you prefer a milder option.
Minced Parsley – Freshens up your salad; cilantro can be used for a different herbaceous note.
Yellow Mustard – Introduces a zesty flavor; Dijon mustard can replace it for a more sophisticated twist.
Black Pepper & Onion Powder – Essential seasonings that elevate the overall taste of your potato salad.
Hard Boiled Eggs – Provide creaminess and protein; make sure to dice them finely for even distribution throughout.

Now that you have all the ingredients gathered, you’re just a few steps away from crafting the perfect potato salad. Let’s get cooking!

Step‑by‑Step Instructions for Classic American Potato Salad with Creamy Dressing

Step 1: Prepare Potatoes
Begin by peeling the russet potatoes, then cut them into uniform ¾-inch cubes to ensure even cooking. Place the diced potatoes into a large pot and fill it with cold water, enough to cover the potatoes by about an inch. This helps prevent browning while they sit.

Step 2: Cook Potatoes
Bring the pot of water to a rolling boil over high heat, then add a generous pinch of kosher salt to enhance the flavor. Lower the heat to a simmer and cook the potatoes for about 8 to 10 minutes, or until they are fork-tender but still firm enough to hold their shape. Drain and return them to the pot.

Step 3: Marinate with Vinegar
While the potatoes are still warm, drizzle the distilled white vinegar over them in the pot. Gently stir to coat the potatoes evenly, then allow them to sit for 20 minutes. This step is essential for the Classic American Potato Salad as it helps the potatoes absorb the tangy flavor, enhancing the overall taste.

Step 4: Combine Ingredients
In a large mixing bowl, combine the marinated potatoes with mayonnaise, chopped celery, dill pickle relish, diced red onions, minced parsley, yellow mustard, black pepper, and onion powder. Using a spatula, stir gently to avoid mashing the potatoes while ensuring everything is well mixed. Taste and adjust seasonings as needed.

Step 5: Chill and Serve
Once everything is combined, cover the bowl with plastic wrap and refrigerate the potato salad for at least 1 hour to let the flavors meld. Before serving, give it a gentle stir and garnish with extra parsley and celery for a fresh touch. Enjoy your delicious, creamy potato salad at your next summer BBQ or family picnic!

How to Store and Freeze Potato Salad

Fridge: Store your potato salad in an airtight container for up to 2 days to maintain its freshness and flavor.

Freezer: For longer storage, freeze in a resealable bag for up to 1 month. Allow it to thaw in the fridge overnight before serving.

Reheating: If you prefer warm potato salad, gently heat it in a saucepan over low heat, adding a splash of mayo if needed for creaminess.

Serving: Always give your potato salad a good stir before serving, as separation may occur during storage. Enjoy your delicious potato salad at family gatherings!

Make Ahead Options

These Classic American Potato Salad preparations make meal prepping a breeze! You can cook and marinate the potatoes up to 24 hours in advance; simply follow the first three steps of the recipe, letting the potatoes soak in vinegar to enrich their flavor. Store them tightly covered in the fridge. The remaining ingredients—like mayonnaise and veggies—can be prepared a day ahead as well, but remember to add them just before serving to maintain that creamy texture. Refrigerate the salad for at least 1 hour before your gathering, ensuring every bite is just as delicious and fresh as if you made it that day. Enjoy the time saved while still delighting your guests with this crowd-pleasing potato salad!

What to Serve with Classic American Potato Salad with Creamy Dressing

Prepare your summer spread with vibrant sides that elevate the creamy comfort of this classic dish.

Grilled Burgers: Juicy, perfectly grilled burgers provide a savory contrast, allowing the coolness of the potato salad to shine alongside. They create an unforgettable pairing that makes you savor every bite.
Barbecue Chicken: The smoky, tangy flavors of barbecue chicken blend seamlessly with the potato salad, enhancing the overall experience of your summer feast.
Fresh Fruit Salad: A colorful assortment of seasonal fruits adds a burst of sweetness and juiciness that balances the richness of the creamy potato salad. Think bright melons, berries, and citrus for a refreshing medley.
Corn on the Cob: Sweet, buttery corn on the cob is a nostalgic summer staple that complements the salad’s texture beautifully. Grilled or boiled, they add that quintessential summer feel to your meal.
Coleslaw: Crunchy and tangy coleslaw brings a zesty kick that contrasts the salad’s creaminess while enriching the flavor profile of your BBQ spread.
Sweet Tea or Lemonade: Wash it all down with refreshing sweet tea or tangy lemonade—the perfect thirst-quenchers that harmonize well with the richness of the potato salad.
Chocolate Chip Cookies: End your meal on a sweet note! Soft and chewy chocolate chip cookies offer a comforting dessert that everyone loves, making it the ultimate picnic finale.

Potato Salad Variations & Substitutions

Feel free to get creative and make this potato salad your own with these delightful variations!

Hawaiian Twist: Add chopped ham, diced Fuji apples, or crushed pineapple for a tropical flair. The sweetness of the fruit complements the creamy dressing beautifully.
Waxy Potatoes: Swap russets for Yukon Gold potatoes for a firmer texture that holds up well in salads. They have a slightly buttery taste that enhances the dish.
Flavorful Mustard: Experiment with different mustards like Dijon or spicy brown to add a nice kick. A dash of smoked paprika can also lend a wonderful depth of flavor.
Herb Variations: Substitute parsley with fresh dill or cilantro for a fresh spin. Each herb brings its unique flavor profile, awakening the taste buds.
Heat it Up: Add diced jalapeños or a dash of hot sauce to introduce some spice. This will make your potato salad an exciting option for heat-lovers!
Creamy Alternatives: For a lighter version, substitute half of the mayonnaise with Greek yogurt or sour cream. This adds creaminess while reducing calories.
Veggie Boost: Toss in some diced bell peppers or shredded carrots for added crunch and color. They add a delightful crunch that brightens the overall dish.
Bacon Lover’s Delight: Crumble crispy bacon on top before serving for a savory finish. The smoky and salty elements bring out the creaminess of the salad.

Once you’ve tried these variations, you might also want to check out delicious side options like Beet Burrata Salad or Crack Corn Salad to complete your summer spread!

Expert Tips for Classic American Potato Salad

Potato Choice: Use russet potatoes for a fluffy texture. Avoid waxy potatoes which can lead to a creamy consistency that’s too dense.
Cooking Time: Check for fork-tenderness around 8 minutes to ensure potatoes hold their shape and avoid mushiness.
Vinegar Magic: Marinating the warm potatoes in vinegar is crucial; it enhances flavor absorption and keeps the potato salad fresh-tasting.
Cool First: Let potatoes cool completely before adding mayonnaise. This prevents the dressing from becoming runny and ensures a creamy potato salad.
Taste Test: Always taste and adjust seasonings before chilling. Flavors mellow in the fridge, and you want it to shine when serving!

Classic American Potato Salad with Creamy Dressing Recipe FAQs

How do I choose the right potatoes for potato salad?
Absolutely! For the best results, opt for russet potatoes—they offer a fluffy texture that beautifully holds up in salad. Look for firm potatoes without any dark spots. If you like a firmer texture, Yukon Golds are also an excellent option.

What’s the best way to store leftover potato salad?
For sure! Keep your potato salad in an airtight container and store it in the refrigerator. It should remain fresh for up to 2 days. If you’re making it ahead of time, it also freezes well—just transfer it to a resealable bag where it can last up to 1 month!

How do I freeze potato salad properly?
Very good question! To freeze your potato salad, scoop the cooled salad into a resealable freezer bag, ensuring you remove as much air as possible before sealing. Lay it flat for even freezing. When you’re ready to eat it, thaw it in the fridge overnight. If you find it a bit dry, add a touch of mayo to bring back the creaminess!

Why is my potato salad too mushy?
The key to avoiding mushiness is cooking your potatoes just right! Make sure to simmer them only until fork-tender, about 8-10 minutes. Overcooking will result in a salad that’s too soft. Also, always cool them before mixing with the dressing to prevent separation. A good check is to test a piece of potato before draining—if it holds its shape, you’re golden!

Is potato salad safe for pets or those with allergies?
Definitely! While potato salad can be a delicious side for humans, keep in mind it’s not suitable for pets—especially if it contains onions or mayo, which can be harmful to them. Additionally, if you have specific dietary concerns, be sure to substitute ingredients like mayonnaise with a vegan alternative or omit items like eggs to accommodate allergies.