Name: Delicious Copycat Nutter Butters: A Nostalgic Homemade Treat
Prep time: 20 min
Cook time: 10 min
Total time: 35 min
Ingredients: 1 cup Unsalted Butter (softened); 1 cup Creamy Peanut Butter; 1 cup Granulated Sugar (can be replaced with coconut sugar); 1/2 cup Brown Sugar (adds moisture and flavor); 1 large Egg (can substitute with aquafaba); 1 teaspoon Vanilla Extract (consider vanilla bean for richness); 2 cups All-Purpose Flour (or gluten-free blend); 1 teaspoon Baking Soda; 1/2 teaspoon Salt (or sea salt); 1 cup Powdered Sugar (can add cornstarch for stability); 2 tablespoons Milk (use dairy-free options as needed)

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

There’s nothing quite like the irresistible pull of a classic childhood snack, and these Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters deliver all the nostalgia with an upgraded twist. You’ll be embracing the wonderful world of soft, chewy peanut butter cookies with a luscious filling that’s bound to rekindle fond memories. Whipping up these delightful treats is a breeze, making them the perfect sweet solution for busy weeknights or playful afternoons. Not only are they crowd-pleasers, but they also outshine any store-bought version you’ve ever encountered. Get ready to savor that homemade comfort in every delicious bite! So, what’s stopping you from diving into this delightful cookie adventure?

Why are Copycat Nutter Butters irresistible?

Nostalgic Flavors: Each bite takes you back to childhood with that familiar taste of peanut butter and sweetness.
Easy Preparation: No complicated techniques needed—just mix, scoop, and bake!
Crowd Favorite: These cookies are perfect for parties, providing a delightful treat that everyone will enjoy.
Versatile Enjoyment: Enjoy them as a dessert, snack, or pack them into lunchboxes for a comforting surprise.
Freshness Guaranteed: Unlike store-bought cookies, these are made fresh, so you can savor the homemade goodness without preservatives.
With their warm, chewy texture and sweet-salty filling, these homemade treats outshine any packaged snack on the shelf. Give them a try and taste the difference for yourself!

Copycat Nutter Butters Ingredients

• The key to making these delightful cookies is in the quality of your ingredients!

For the Cookies

Unsalted Butter (softened) – Adds richness and moisture; substitute with vegan butter for a dairy-free version.
Creamy Peanut Butter – Provides the foundational flavor and texture; avoid natural brands as they may be too oily.
Granulated Sugar – Sweetens the cookies and helps achieve the right texture; can be replaced with coconut sugar for a less processed option.
Brown Sugar – Adds moisture and a slight caramel flavor; while no direct substitutes exist, using all granulated sugar can work in a pinch.
Egg – Binds the ingredients for structure; aquafaba can substitute (3 tablespoons = 1 egg) for a vegan option.
Vanilla Extract – Elevates flavor complexity; consider using a vanilla bean or paste for a richer aroma.
All-Purpose Flour – Provides structure to the cookies; for a gluten-free variant, substitute with a 1:1 gluten-free flour blend.
Baking Soda – Leavens the cookies for the right rise; no substitutes are available, making it critical for texture.
Salt – Balances sweetness and enhances flavor; replace with sea salt for a contrasting taste profile.

For the Filling

Powdered Sugar – Sweetens and thickens the filling; cornstarch can add stability in humid conditions.
Milk – Adjusts the filling’s consistency; opt for dairy-free alternatives like almond or oat milk.

Dive into the blissful world of homemade Copycat Nutter Butters and experience the heartwarming satisfaction that no store-bought cookie can match!

Step‑by‑Step Instructions for Copycat Nutter Butters

Step 1: Preheat the Oven
Begin by preheating your oven to 350°F (175°C). This ensures that your Copycat Nutter Butters will bake evenly. While the oven warms up, you can prepare the cookie dough, giving you a seamless flow into the baking process.

Step 2: Cream the Butters and Sugars
In a large mixing bowl, combine softened unsalted butter, creamy peanut butter, brown sugar, and granulated sugar. Using an electric mixer, blend these ingredients on medium speed for about 2–3 minutes until the mixture becomes light and fluffy. This texture is vital for achieving that soft and chewy cookie everyone will love.

Step 3: Incorporate Egg and Vanilla
Next, beat in one egg and a splash of vanilla extract to your creamed mixture. Mix on low speed until everything is well incorporated, which should take about 1 minute. You’ll notice the dough getting smoother and more cohesive, setting the stage for the dry ingredients.

Step 4: Combine Dry Ingredients
In a separate bowl, whisk together the all-purpose flour, baking soda, and salt until evenly mixed. This step will ensure that your Copycat Nutter Butters have the right rise and texture. Take care to break up any lumps in the flour for a consistent dough.

Step 5: Mix Dry and Wet Ingredients
Gradually add your dry mixture into the wet ingredients, mixing on low speed until just combined. Avoid over-mixing, as it can lead to tougher cookies; you want the dough to be slightly sticky and ready to form into balls.

Step 6: Shape the Cookies
Using a cookie scoop or your hands, portion out the dough into small balls, about 1 inch in diameter. Place them onto a baking sheet lined with parchment paper, slightly flattening each dough ball with your palm or the bottom of a glass to create a uniform shape. This will allow for even baking.

Step 7: Bake the Cookies
Bake your cookies in the preheated oven for approximately 10 minutes or until the edges are lightly golden. The centers may look a bit soft, but don’t worry; they will firm up as they cool. Allow them to cool on the baking sheet for a few minutes before transferring them to a wire rack.

Step 8: Prepare the Filling
While the cookies cool, prepare the filling by beating together softened unsalted butter, creamy peanut butter, powdered sugar, and a splash of vanilla in a bowl. Adjust the consistency with milk as needed — you want it creamy yet spreadable. This filling adds that signature richness to your Copycat Nutter Butters.

Step 9: Assemble the Sandwiches
Once the cookies have completely cooled, take one cookie and spread a generous layer of filling on the flat side. Top it with another cookie, pressing down gently to adhere. Repeat this for all cookies, creating delightful peanut butter sandwiches reminiscent of the classic treat.

Expert Tips for Copycat Nutter Butters

Chill the Dough: If the dough feels too soft, chill it for 15–20 minutes before shaping. This helps achieve better cookie textures without spreading too much during baking.
Watch the Bake Time: Keep a close eye on your cookies; they should be lightly golden at the edges to maintain that irresistible soft center. Overbaked cookies can become hard instead of chewy.
Storage Secrets: Store your Copycat Nutter Butters in an airtight container for up to 5 days. To keep them soft, add a slice of bread to the container; it helps maintain moisture.
Filling Consistency: Aim for a creamy filling that’s not too runny. Adjust the milk gradually to achieve just the right texture for spreading between the cookies.
Mix Varieties: For a fun twist, mix in some chocolate chips or chopped peanuts into the dough for added flavor and crunch. These small changes can create unique variations everyone will love!

Copycat Nutter Butters Variations

Feel free to get creative with your Copycat Nutter Butters and make them uniquely yours!

Nut-Free: Use sunflower seed butter in place of peanut butter for a delightful, allergy-friendly twist. You won’t miss the peanuts one bit!
Chocolate Boost: Mix in dark chocolate or white chocolate chips into the dough for indulgent pockets of joy. This adds a luscious touch that chocolate lovers will savor.
Crunchy Surprise: Add chopped peanuts to the filling for a delightful crunch that contrasts beautifully with the creamy texture. It’s the perfect way to elevate that nostalgic favorite!
Gluten-Free: Substitute regular flour with a 1:1 gluten-free flour blend to cater to gluten sensitivities without sacrificing taste. Enjoy soft cookies that everyone can share.
Dairy-Free: Swap out traditional butter and milk for coconut oil and almond milk, keeping the delightful flavor profile intact while accommodating dairy restrictions.
Maple Sweetened: Replace granulated sugar with pure maple syrup for a more earthy and less processed sweetness. Just remember to adjust the flour to maintain a proper dough consistency.
Spiced Delight: Add a pinch of cinnamon or pumpkin spice to the dough to infuse warmth and cozy notes, perfect for chilly days. This creative twist will remind you of fall!
Fruity Filling: Add a layer of your favorite fruit jam or preserves between the cookies and filling for a refreshing burst of flavor. A hint of raspberries or strawberries could elevate each bite.

Explore these variations and let your imagination run wild with your Copycat Nutter Butters. New flavors await as sweet memories come alive!

What to Serve with Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters

Indulge in the nostalgia of these delightful cookies while discovering perfect pairings that elevate snack time or dessert to a whole new level.

Chilled Milk: The classic pairing! A glass of cold milk effortlessly balances the sweet and salty flavors, enhancing every bite of the peanut butter cookie.
Dark Roast Coffee: Rich, bold coffee brings out the cookies’ sweetness, making it a great pairing for adult gatherings or early morning treats.
Vanilla Ice Cream: Creamy vanilla ice cream complements the chewy texture and peanut butter richness, creating a dreamy dessert sandwich when layered between cookies.
Fresh Fruit Salad: Bright, juicy fruits add a refreshing contrast to the cookies’ indulgence, making for a balanced dessert platter that’s visually stunning.
Chocolate Dipped Strawberries: The sweetness of strawberries dipped in chocolate brings sophistication, making every bite feel like a special occasion when enjoyed alongside your Nutter Butters.
Nutty Granola: A side of nutty granola offers crunch and flavor diversity, making your dessert more interesting while maintaining that nutty theme.
Herbal Tea: A soothing cup of herbal tea, like chamomile or mint, provides a calming contrast, perfect for late-night indulgence or cozy afternoons.
Peanut Butter Smoothie: For those who love a protein boost, blend up a smooth, creamy peanut butter smoothie—it’s a fun and energetic accompaniment to the cookies!
Brownies: For true dessert lovers, a fudgy brownie creates a decadent duo when served on a plate with your Copycat Nutter Butters, appealing to every sweet tooth.

Enjoy these pairings, and let your culinary creativity shine as you explore various ways to savor your homemade Copycat Nutter Butters!

Make Ahead Options

These Homemade Copycat Nutter Butters are perfect for meal prep enthusiasts! You can prepare the cookie dough up to 24 hours in advance. Simply mix the dough, wrap it tightly in plastic wrap, and refrigerate to maintain that fresh flavor. The cookies can also be baked and stored in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 5 days or refrigerated for 10 days. For the filling, prepare it ahead of time and store it in the fridge; just give it a quick stir before using. When you’re ready to assemble, layer the filling between cookies, and you’ll have freshly made treats with minimal effort!

How to Store and Freeze Copycat Nutter Butters

Room Temperature: Store your Copycat Nutter Butters in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 5 days to keep them fresh and chewy.

Fridge: For extended freshness, refrigerate the cookies in an airtight container for up to 10 days. This helps maintain moisture and flavor.

Freezer: To freeze, place unbaked cookie dough balls on a parchment-lined baking sheet until firm, then transfer them to a freezer-safe bag. They can be frozen for up to 2 months—just bake from frozen, adding an extra minute or two to the bake time.

Reheating: If you prefer warm cookies, reheat them in a microwave for about 10-15 seconds or in a 350°F (175°C) oven for a few minutes until heated through. Enjoy the soft, delightful experience they offer!

Copycat Nutter Butters Recipe FAQs

How do I select the best peanut butter for this recipe?
Absolutely! For the best flavor and texture, choose a creamy peanut butter that isn’t too oily. Regular brands work well, while natural peanut butters may result in cookies that are too greasy. Look for one that has just peanuts and salt for a lovely balance.

What’s the best way to store Copycat Nutter Butters?
Storing these delightful cookies is easy! Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 5 days. For optimal freshness, you can refrigerate them for up to 10 days. If you’re short on time, try adding a slice of bread to the container—it helps retain moisture and keeps your cookies soft!

Can I freeze the cookie dough? How do I do it?
Yes, you can absolutely freeze the dough! First, scoop the dough into small balls and place them on a parchment-lined baking sheet. Freeze until firm, then transfer the balls to a freezer-safe bag. They can be stored for up to 2 months. When it’s time to bake, just add an extra minute or two to the bake time when starting from frozen!

What should I do if my cookie dough is too soft?
If your dough feels too soft to handle, don’t worry! Chill it in the refrigerator for 15–20 minutes. This will firm it up, making it easier to shape into balls without spreading out too much while baking. Trust me, this small step makes a big difference for the final texture!

Are there any allergy considerations with this recipe?
Very! This recipe contains peanut butter, which can be an allergen for many people. If you’re making these for someone with a nut allergy, you can use sunflower seed butter as an alternative. Just ensure that all other ingredients are free from cross-contamination with nuts. Enjoy baking safely!

How can I add extra flavors to my Copycat Nutter Butters?
The more, the merrier! To get creative, consider adding chocolate chips or even chopped peanuts to the dough for added texture and taste. You could also replace some of the granulated sugar with brown sugar for a deeper flavor. Enjoy experimenting while keeping the nostalgic essence intact!